Home  /  Indian Succession Act  /  Section 181

Section 181: Devolution of interest relinquished by owner

Indian Succession Act • Official Statutory Text & Practice Guide

Statutory Regulation
Legal Standard
Competent Court / Tribunal
Act 1925
Section 180 All 391 Sections of Indian Succession Act Section 182

Legal Commentary & Landmark Judgments: Section 181

Section 181 regulates the devolution of a relinquished legacy, providing that the benefit surrendered by a dissenting owner devolves as if it had not been disposed of, subject to compensating the disappointed legatee.

  • Core Legal Standard: Section 181 governs the legal fate of a legacy forfeited by a beneficiary who elects against the will.
  • Operational Mechanism: Where the owner of property which the testator professed to dispose of elects to retain their own property and dissents from the will, they must relinquish the legacy bequeathed to them.

Under Section 181, the relinquished legacy does not vanish; it devolves upon the testator's personal representatives or residuary estate as property undisposed of by will, but subject to a paramount equitable charge: it must first be applied to compensate the disappointed legatee (the person whose gift of the owner's property was defeated by the election) up to the fair value of the lost bequest.

Key Landmark Precedents:
  • Pramod Kumar Jaiswal v. Bibi Husn Bano, (2005) 5 SCC 492: The Supreme Court highlighted that under Section 181, the relinquished interest provides compensation to the disappointed legatee, ensuring that equity fulfills the economic intention of the testator as closely as possible.
  • Beepathuma v. Shankaranarayana Kadambolithaya, AIR 1965 SC 241: The Supreme Court recognized that Section 181 enforces the principle of equitable compensation arising from the exercise of an election.
Legal Commentary:

Section 181 protects disappointed beneficiaries. If a father leaves A's house to B, and leaves Rs. 10 lakhs to A, and A elects to keep his house, A forfeits the Rs. 10 lakhs. Under Section 181, B can claim compensation out of that forfeited Rs. 10 lakhs up to the value of the house, preventing B from ending up empty-handed.

Section 180 All 391 Sections of Indian Succession Act Section 182