Home  /  Indian Succession Act  /  Section 89

Section 89: Will or bequest void for uncertainty

Indian Succession Act • Official Statutory Text & Practice Guide

Statutory Regulation
Legal Standard
Competent Court / Tribunal
Act 1925
Section 88 All 391 Sections of Indian Succession Act Section 90

Legal Commentary & Landmark Judgments: Section 89

Section 89 renders void any will or bequest not expressive of any definite intention, or of which the meaning is not possible to be ascertained.

  • Core Legal Standard: Section 89 codifies the doctrine of voidness for uncertainty.
  • Operational Mechanism: If a will, or any individual bequest within a will, is so vague, obscure, or incomprehensible that it is impossible for the court to ascertain what property is intended to be disposed of, or what person is intended to be benefited, the disposition is wholly void.

Uncertainty may relate to the subject (e.g., 'I leave some of my land to A' or 'a handsome gift to B') or to the object (e.g., 'I leave my house to one of my cousins'). However, the threshold for declaring a bequest void under Section 89 is extremely high. The court will not strike down a bequest for uncertainty if its meaning can be extracted through reasonable construction, contextual inquiry under Section 75, or extrinsic evidence under Section 80. Voidness for uncertainty is a desperate remedy invoked only when all interpretive tools fail.

Key Landmark Precedents:
  • Dinanath v. Dayanand, AIR 1978 Del 195: The Delhi High Court held that a bequest cannot be declared void for uncertainty under Section 89 unless it is utterly impossible to resolve the testator's intention through reasonable judicial construction.
  • Gnambal Ammal v. T. Raju Ayyar, AIR 1951 SC 103: The Supreme Court observed that the court must make every endeavor to find a definite meaning before condemning a testamentary gift as void under Section 89.
Legal Commentary:

Section 89 is the premier weapon for statutory heirs seeking to knock out ambiguous bequests. If a testator uses discretionary or vague words without naming an executor to make the selection, the clause collapses under Section 89, and the asset falls into the residue or devolves under intestacy. Litigators must plead specific failure of both subject and object to trigger Section 89.

Section 88 All 391 Sections of Indian Succession Act Section 90