Section 109: When bequest to testator's child or lineal descendant does not lapse on his death in testator's lifetime

Indian Succession Act • Official Statutory Text & Practice Guide

Statutory Regulation
Legal Standard
Competent Court / Tribunal
Act 1925

Legal Commentary & Landmark Judgments: Section 109

Section 109 codifies the landmark statutory anti-lapse protection for children and lineal descendants, providing that a bequest to a child does not lapse if the child dies leaving issue surviving the testator.

  • Core Legal Standard: Section 109 enacts a major statutory exception to the doctrine of lapse to protect family continuity.
  • Operational Mechanism: Where a bequest has been made to any child or other lineal descendant of the testator, and that child or descendant dies in the lifetime of the testator leaving issue (children or grandchildren), and any such issue is alive at the time of the testator's death, the bequest does NOT lapse.

The profound legal mechanic of Section 109 is a statutory fiction: the legacy takes effect as if the death of the legatee had happened immediately after the death of the testator, unless a contrary intention appears by the will. Consequently, the bequest passes into the estate of the deceased child and is governed by that deceased child's will or intestate succession, ensuring that the child's surviving family is not disinherited.

Key Landmark Precedents:
  • Suraj Pal v. Ram Kol, AIR 1952 All 324: The court delivered an exhaustive analysis of Section 109, holding that the statutory anti-lapse fiction preserves the legacy for the estate of a deceased child who left surviving issue, overriding the general rule of lapse.
  • Mary Roy v. State of Kerala, (1986) 2 SCC 209: The Supreme Court observed that statutory succession rules under Section 109 demonstrate legislative commitment to protecting dependent family branches.
Legal Commentary:

Section 109 contains a critical legal subtlety: the legacy does NOT go directly to the grandchildren! Under the statutory fiction, it passes into the *estate* of the deceased child. Therefore, if the deceased child left a will, the legacy passes according to the child's will; if the child had creditors, the legacy is subject to those debts. Practitioners must trace the administration of the deceased child's estate to claim funds saved under Section 109.