Section 175: Passing of resolution by circulation

Companies Act • Official Statutory Text & Practice Guide

Statutory Regulation
Legal Standard
Competent Court / Tribunal
Act 2013
Statutory Defined Terms in this Section: (Click any term for official legal definition)

Legal Commentary & Landmark Judgments: Section 175

Section 175 of the Companies Act, 2013 establishes the statutory procedure and safeguards for the Board of Directors or its committees to adopt resolutions by circulation without convening a formal physical or audio-visual meeting, conditioning legal validity upon universal dispatch and requisite majority approval.

  • Mandatory Dispatch to Every Director: The draft resolution, accompanied by all necessary explanatory notes and material papers, must be circulated to all directors or committee members at their addresses registered with the company in India by hand delivery, post, courier, or electronic means (such as email). Circulating the proposal to every director entitled to receive notice is a strict condition precedent; failure to send the draft to even a single director renders the circular resolution void ab initio.
  • Requisite Approving Majority: The resolution is validly passed only if it is approved by a majority of the directors or committee members who are entitled to vote on the resolution. Directors who are interested in the transaction under Section 184 are statutorily disentitled from participating, voting, or being reckoned towards the approving majority.
  • One-Third Minority Veto for Physical Deliberation: Under the proviso to Section 175(1), if not less than one-third of the total number of directors demand that the resolution under circulation be decided at a meeting of the Board, the chairperson is statutorily mandated to place the resolution before a formal Board meeting, immediately terminating the circular route.
  • Subsequent Board Minuting and Recording: Section 175(2) mandates that every resolution passed by circulation must be formally noted at the immediately subsequent meeting of the Board or committee and incorporated into the permanent minutes book; while failure to minute does not vitiate the resolution if duly passed, it constitutes a managerial default under the Act.
Key Landmark Precedents:
  • Torstar Corpn. v. Jagran Prakashan Ltd., (2005) 125 Comp Cas 844 (CLB): Held that where a circular resolution is passed without dispatching the draft and explanatory notes to all directors, or where notice is deliberately concealed from nominee or minority directors, the resolution is an absolute nullity and non-est in law.
  • R.K. Aggarwal v. Modern Insulators Ltd., (2008) 144 Comp Cas 351 (CLB): Ruled that the statutory right of one-third of directors to requisition a formal board meeting under the proviso to Section 175(1) is absolute and non-derogable; any subsequent adoption of the resolution via circulation despite such requisition is illegal and void.
Courtroom Practice & Strategic Litigation Guidance:

In proceedings challenging circular resolutions before the NCLT under Section 241, call for the transmission logs, electronic read receipts, and courier tracking receipts to establish whether the draft resolution and all supporting materials were concurrently delivered to all directors. If one-third of the board demanded a physical meeting before the voting closure date, plead that the circular resolution was extinguished by operation of law and seek an immediate interim stay of its implementation.