Home  /  Code on Wages, 2019  /  Section 20

Section 20: Deductions for damage or loss

The Code on Wages, 2019 (Act No. 29 of 2019) • Official Statutory Text & Plain English Practice Guide

Statutory Mandate
Chapter III: Payment of Wages
Competent Labour Forum
Act No. 29 of 2019
Section 19 All 67 Sections of Code on Wages, 2019 Section 21

Legal Commentary & Landmark Judgments: Section 20

Section 20 authorizes wage deductions for damage to or loss of goods expressly entrusted to an employee's custody, or for loss of money for which the employee is bound to account, provided such loss is directly attributable to the employee's neglect or default following a fair opportunity to show cause.

  • Express Entrustment Condition: Section 20(1) restricts deductions strictly to instances where damage or loss occurs to goods or money expressly entrusted to the custody of the employee, excluding general commercial risk.
  • Direct Causal Nexus to Neglect or Default: Requires conclusive proof that the damage or loss was directly attributable to the employee's culpable neglect or default, rather than normal wear and tear, systemic error, or third-party theft.
  • Mandatory Natural Justice and Register Entry: Section 20(2) mandates that the employee must be given an opportunity of showing cause before any deduction is made, and all deductions must be entered in the statutory register.
Key Landmark Precedents:
  • National Radio & Electronics Co. Ltd. v. Motion Pictures Employees Union (1998) 1 LLJ 330 (Bom HC): The Bombay High Court held that wage deductions for damage cannot be made without a fair domestic inquiry proving actual physical entrustment and culpable negligence on the part of the employee.
  • Tata Chemicals Ltd. v. Kailash C. Adhvaryu (1964) AIR 1964 Guj 67: The Gujarat High Court held that unilateral managerial recovery of commercial losses or broken materials from workmen's wages without statutory show-cause notice violates principles of natural justice.
Courtroom Practice & Strategic Litigation Guidance:

In defending wage deduction orders before the Section 45 Authority, employers must produce: (1) written custody/entrustment records signed by the employee, (2) an itemized show-cause notice detailing the loss, (3) minutes of the explanation hearing, and (4) certified register entries. Employers cannot deduct commercial bad debts, customer defaults, or unreturned laptops without documented entrustment and inquiry.

Section 19 All 67 Sections of Code on Wages, 2019 Section 21